Message boards : Cafe LHC : Gravity wave center
Message board moderation

To post messages, you must log in.

AuthorMessage
Ernesto Solis

Send message
Joined: 22 Aug 05
Posts: 100
Credit: 6,864
RAC: 0
Message 13666 - Posted: 19 May 2006, 6:20:39 UTC
Last modified: 19 May 2006, 6:25:13 UTC

Can someone help me with this question.
I've noticed that NGC 1300,2442,1365 and our Milky Way Galaxy all have a Bar of stars at the center. Does this have anything in common with the modal of the gravity wave center?
What forms the bar?

Ernie S
Team Art Bell
God Bless
ID: 13666 · Report as offensive     Reply Quote
Ernesto Solis

Send message
Joined: 22 Aug 05
Posts: 100
Credit: 6,864
RAC: 0
Message 13764 - Posted: 28 May 2006, 3:01:33 UTC - in response to Message 13666.  

Can someone help me with this question.
I've noticed that NGC 1300,2442,1365 and our Milky Way Galaxy all have a Bar of stars at the center. Does this have anything in common with the modal of the gravity wave center?
What forms the bar?

Ernie S
Team Art Bell
God Bless


Mike H from another Boinc project (Einstein@home) helped me with the question.
I always like to share...
Ernie S

In all the years that bars have been observed, I don't think a sustained explanation has been found. The difficulty is what is visible vs what is not. Models based purely on luminous matter distribution run into difficulties, as the observed tangential velocities of stars as a function of radial distance from galactic centre doesn't fall off fast enough. This eventually lead to the concept of 'dark matter' which, by definition, allegedly contributes to such dynamics but is unseen. ( Don't confuse this with 'dark energy' which refers to a quite unrelated idea on a vaster cosmological scale ) Until a full accounting is achieved of all gravitationally active elements then explanations of all structural patterns remain moot.
Cheers, Mike
ID: 13764 · Report as offensive     Reply Quote
Ernesto Solis

Send message
Joined: 22 Aug 05
Posts: 100
Credit: 6,864
RAC: 0
Message 13765 - Posted: 28 May 2006, 3:05:27 UTC - in response to Message 13764.  

Can someone help me with this question.
I've noticed that NGC 1300,2442,1365 and our Milky Way Galaxy all have a Bar of stars at the center. Does this have anything in common with the modal of the gravity wave center?
What forms the bar?

Ernie S
Team Art Bell
God Bless


Mike H from another Boinc project (Einstein@home) helped me with the question.
I always like to share...
Ernie S

In all the years that bars have been observed, I don't think a sustained explanation has been found. The difficulty is what is visible vs what is not. Models based purely on luminous matter distribution run into difficulties, as the observed tangential velocities of stars as a function of radial distance from galactic centre doesn't fall off fast enough. This eventually lead to the concept of 'dark matter' which, by definition, allegedly contributes to such dynamics but is unseen. ( Don't confuse this with 'dark energy' which refers to a quite unrelated idea on a vaster cosmological scale ) Until a full accounting is achieved of all gravitationally active elements then explanations of all structural patterns remain moot.
Cheers, Mike


In all the years that bars.........structural patterns remain moot.

I've just looked a few things up.
If we judge matters upon visible stuff alone, then the overall/average tangential velocities of stars in a galaxy should fall off like the inverse square root of the radius from galactic centre. This is very similiar to our own solar system, and is a 'Keplerian' distribution if you like.
However for very many galaxies looked at to date the measured velocities are pretty constant ( ie. not subsiding ) with radius, and out to a considerable distance too. It is posed therefore that a globular distribution of invisible material ( aka dark matter ), also centred on the galactic centre as visibly defined, would explain things. If so one can deduce some properties of said dark matter.
Now some observations have shown that no edge has yet to be defined for the extension of such dark matter into intergalactic space. I think the motions of smaller satellite galaxies similiar to our Magellenic clouds in the Milky Way were considered here. This raises the serious possibility of vast extensions of dark matter into what are otherwise deemed 'voids', many galactic radii away.
Studies of gravitational lensing of light from some galaxy clusters have deduced the presence of considerable non-luminous mass that contributes to the bending of the light. ( The entire material produces multiple images of some other galaxy or object well behind the cluster as viewed by us. By analysing the images carefully one can uniquely determine the mass distribution that produced it ).
Cheers, Mike

ID: 13765 · Report as offensive     Reply Quote
Ernesto Solis

Send message
Joined: 22 Aug 05
Posts: 100
Credit: 6,864
RAC: 0
Message 14221 - Posted: 2 Jul 2006, 6:33:20 UTC

Story on "The Great Attractor"

http://www.world-science.net/exclusives/060419_attractorfrm.htm

Ernie S
Team Art Bell
God Bless
ID: 14221 · Report as offensive     Reply Quote
Ernesto Solis

Send message
Joined: 22 Aug 05
Posts: 100
Credit: 6,864
RAC: 0
Message 14397 - Posted: 21 Jul 2006, 19:37:39 UTC

Frome Ben at Einstein@home:

Actually you can say a lot about galactic structure without knowing where the dark matter is. The spiral arms in spiral galaxies are density waves propagating around the galactic disk due to its rotation. They're not all that different from hurricanes in some ways, but on a grand scale. Instead of a little air getting squeezed so that water droplets condense on a timescale of hours and produce an "arm" of clouds, you've got the interstellar gas getting squeezed so that it condenses on a timescale of millions of years and produces stars. The spiral arm propagates because the biggest stars burn fast and die in big explosions, which push out bubbles in the interstellar medium and compress the next bit of gas further around the galactic disk, which makes more stars down there, which blow ... and so on.

There is some thought that spiral galaxies are just ellipticals that got these waves triggered by close encounters or mergers with other galaxies. Our galaxy is surrounded by several little satellite galaxies (including the Magellanic Clouds which you can see in the southern sky) and a shredded streamer of stars which looks like another one in the process of being eaten. So it looks like we had a "recent" (less than a billion years) encounter with another galaxy that got ripped up and gave us our spirals.

If I recall correctly, bars are basically the same but involve the concentration of gas and dust near the center of the galaxy which generally has different dynamics from the disk out where we (and the spiral arms) live.

Hope this helps,

Ben

ID: 14397 · Report as offensive     Reply Quote

Message boards : Cafe LHC : Gravity wave center


©2024 CERN